Meet the Author: Monica Iyer

Monica Iyer is an international human rights lawyer and legal scholar whose work examines how climate change, gender, race and migration intersect in law. An Assistant Professor of Law at Georgia State University College of Law, Iyer draws on a career that has taken her from the New York State Office of the Attorney General to the United Nations Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) before she moved into the classroom. In this interview, she reflects on why she sees teaching as a multiplier of impact, how the concept of “petro-masculinity” helps explain the structures behind fossil fuel dependence, and why climate migration is too often misunderstood as a problem of security and numbers rather than one of rights and belonging. Her answers offer a case for scholarship that is both rigorous and committed to change.


Q: You’ve worked at the UN, in government, and now in academia what drew you to teaching, and how has that mix of experience shaped the way you approach research and the classroom?

A: I was very fortunate to work at the UN in an area that is cutting edge and that I’m passionate about: the intersection of climate change and human rights. Being there, while the law was actively being developed, showed me how much more thinking the field needs. There is a lot of theory to work through, and academic engagement can help build the law in this space. A great deal of law still needs to be made.

Teaching also feels like a force multiplier. I can do the work myself, but I can also train students, many of whom are smarter than me and have very particular skills, and send them out into the world to do more and to add to the work I want to see done. So I was drawn to both: building ideas in a new and emerging area and enabling others to build ideas and contribute.

Q: Your academic path took you from Chicago to NYU to Milan before landing in international human rights law. How did that international education shape the lens you bring to your scholarship?

A: An international perspective is essential, especially on a global issue like climate change. Having studied in so many different places, and having talked with people who are confronting the impacts of climate change on their human rights around the world, means my scholarship isn’t limited to one context. It is grounded in people’s actual lived experiences in a variety of places.

Q: You’ve described teaching as a “multiplier of impact.” Could you say more about what that means to you, and how it compares to the kind of impact you had working directly on human rights issues at the UN or in government?

A: To me it means a different kind of collaboration. Every job I’ve had has been collaborative, but teaching is collaboration for and with the future. It’s a special kind of job, building students. It also means letting go of a little control, because you’re giving very smart, very dedicated people the skills and knowledge they need to go out and do what they want with them in the world. You don’t have the same sense of completing a task yourself. Instead, you’re giving other people the ability to complete the tasks they care about.

Q: A lot of your recent work sits at the intersection of climate change, gender, and human rights. What first drew you to studying that intersection, rather than treating these as separate fields?

A: They’re not separate things. What drew me to this intersection is understanding how deeply connected they are.

A lot of my recent work has been around the concept of “petro-masculinity,” coined by the scholar Cara Daggett. The idea is that gender shapes our understanding of climate and the environment, and of how people interact with them, and that this in turn influences our political choices. Specifically, there is a social and cultural association between exploiting fossil fuels and a certain kind of strong, hegemonic masculinity, which we perceive as the strongest version of humanity and of politics. The belief is that we need that masculinity in order to succeed and to make progress as a society. In Daggett’s formulation, we then need authoritarian states, or authoritarian measures, to protect that masculinity and the fossil fuel industry.

This isn’t the only way people perceive the world, but I think it’s a very strong explainer for some of the ways people interact with it. And if we try to address climate change without dealing with the structural issues and societal perceptions that lead us to keep exploiting fossil fuels, we will fail. We have to understand them all as connected.


Q: You argue that petro-masculinity is embedded not just in culture but in law itself through treaties, courts, and policy. Can you give an example of what that looks like in practice?

A: I’ve been looking at this in both US domestic law and international law, as an international lawyer. In the US, the Trump administration offers very vivid examples. Its executive orders and its rollback of environmental action are centred on dominance through fossil fuels, and the phrase “energy dominance” comes up again and again in its language.

It’s also reflected, in more subtle ways, in US law, particularly in recent Supreme Court cases on the environment. There is a tendency to treat fossil fuel companies, oil companies and car manufacturers as the most rational actors in the system, the ones whose perspective is correct and scientific. Concern for the environment, by contrast, is dismissed as hysteria or emotion. Those are qualities coded as feminine, which we don’t think belong in our “sane” legal imagination, and they get rejected in favour of what fossil fuel interests tell us is the most rational response to climate change and environmental harm. I think we see that in a number of recent Supreme Court rulings.

Internationally, the most prominent example is an idea at the core of international law: that national strength and success rest on economic and military power, which in turn depend on fossil fuels. That creates a core tension when countries try to address climate change. They are trying to do so without giving up that particular vision of strength. Because of that, we’re failing to address climate change on a global level.

Q: Your work on climate migration pushes back against framing it purely as a data, security, or legal-categorization problem. Why do you think those framings have dominated the conversation, and what gets lost when they do?

A: I think this is tied again to the idea that a state’s strength and success come from being hard-line: from exclusion, and from defining ourselves against others.

The way we have thought about climate-related migration mirrors the way we have thought about migration generally, and by “we” I mean the often exclusionary countries of the Global North. We think about it in terms of fear and resource scarcity. But climate is almost never the only factor. Migration is almost always multi-causal, and it is a complex decision. Thinking about any kind of migration only in terms of security, or only in terms of potential numbers, stops us from understanding the complexity of the situation. It also stops us from finding solutions that let everyone benefit and reach their full capacities.

Q: Environmental migration is still a relatively new and contested area in international law. What do you see as the biggest misconception people have about it?

A: I think there are two related misconceptions.

The first is that all climate-related or environmental migration is, or will be, movement from the Global South to the Global North. What we actually know is that all forms of migration, including environmental migration, tend to be internal first of all: most displacement happens within a country. When people do cross borders, they still overwhelmingly move within their own region. People try to stay close to home.

That is related to the second misperception, which is that everyone wants to leave. We see over and over again that this isn’t true. The term the literature often uses is “voluntary immobility”, but the fact is that people love their homes. They love the places where they grew up and where their ancestors are from, and they want to preserve them. So even those of us thinking about human rights and migrants tend to ask only how to facilitate migration in a rights-based or humanitarian way. We don’t ask how to enable people to stay in their homes if they want to.

Q: Your scholarship connects gender, race, and environmental harm, themes that don’t always appear together in traditional international law scholarship. Do you see your work as part of a broader shift in the field, or still fairly novel?

A: The field as a whole is fairly new, in terms of thinking about the environment and human rights. I do think my work is part of a shift. A number of other incredible scholars have been working on these issues for many years. Here in the US, I think of people like Maxine Burkett, Carmen Gonzalez and Rebecca Bratspies; in Canada, Sarah Seck; and Penelope Simons. These are established scholars, but there are also some more junior scholars doing incredible work in this area, such as Achinthi Vithanage, Camila Bustos, Kelsey Jost-Creegan, and Sarah Dorman, with whom I’ve worked. 

Q: In developing this emerging discipline, what obstacles have you faced, and to what extent has the field been met with scepticism or criticism?

A: There are always concerns within the academy about the idea of the scholar-activist, or about scholarship that has an agenda. I strongly believe you can be rigorous in your thinking without giving up hope that your work will lead to change. There is obviously a great deal that can be done to make the world better, and if we don’t think our work contributes to that in some way, there doesn’t seem to be much point in doing it. To me, that actually demands greater rigour, because if the work isn’t done well, it won’t contribute to change.

Q: Looking ahead, what do you hope will change in law, policy, or public understanding as a result of the kind of research you’re doing now?

A: People have asked me whether I want everyone in climate negotiations to be saying, “Isn’t that a very petro-masculine way of approaching it?” I don’t see that ever happening. But I do think it’s important for people engaged in law and policymaking to understand the structures that inform their decisions and ways of thinking, so that they start to question habits of thought, built up over decades and even centuries, that aren’t serving us well as we confront the challenges of today and the future.

I would like people to think not just about the immediate problems, such as lowering emissions, but also about the structures that got us here, and how we can address those structures while we lower emissions.


Q: What do you think SSRN contributes to the world of modern research and scholarship?

A: As a junior scholar, I find SSRN enormously helpful. It gives us the opportunity to engage, and to have our work engaged with, in a way that is easy to access. Everything is collected in one place, so it’s easy to understand the full body of a person’s work, and to read work that might otherwise sit behind a paywall.

It’s useful for scholarly exchange and feedback, but it also reaches beyond the academy. I’ve had people who aren’t academics, but who are interested in the world and in ideas, tell me they really value SSRN as a way to look at research and find out what’s happening. So it helps us develop ideas and conversations within the academy, and it also gives us a way to reach a broader public.

MORE ABOUT MONICA IYER

Monica Iyer’s scholarship focuses on the intersection of climate change, the environment and human rights, with particular attention to migration and to racial and gender justice. Her recent work draws on the concept of petro-masculinity to ask how cultural ideas about gender, strength, security and progress become embedded in domestic and international law. Across her research, she argues that climate change cannot be addressed without confronting the social and legal structures that sustain fossil fuel use, and that climate migration should be understood through dignity, justice and agency, including the choice of people to remain in the places they call home. She teaches International Law, International Human Rights Law, and Climate Change Law.

Before joining Georgia State, Iyer was a senior lecturing fellow in the International Human Rights Clinic at Duke University School of Law. Earlier in her career, she worked for the United Nations, government and civil society organisations on issues including the environment and climate change, migration, women’s rights and gender equality, international development and racial justice. She served as a Human Rights Officer at OHCHR and as an assistant attorney general in the Civil Rights Bureau of the New York State Office of the Attorney General. She holds a J.D. from New York University School of Law, a master’s degree in international cooperation and development from the Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore in Milan, and an A.B. from the University of Chicago.

You can see more work by Monica Iyer on her SSRN Author page here.

Leave a Reply